Reducing Computer Noise in the Studio

 

When using a computer-based recording system, there is nothing more unnerving than the incessant whirring of the fan inside the computer and the fragmented and irregular clicks and pops of the hard drives saving, loading, and saving. Many believe that short of spending hundreds of dollars (even thousands!) on specially made enclosures, the only other solution is to remotely locate the computer in a closet or another room. This paper presents a few other solutions worth considering.

But before we get into the solutions, let's discuss the problems in more detail. The good news is that most of the noise generated by our computers is high pitched. High frequencies are much easier to contend with than low frequencies by strategically positioning absorptive materials where they will do the most good. The bad news is that the very reason computers have fans is that they need air to cool themselves or else they will overheat and stop working. So the required solution involves providing a mix of absorption while allowing fresh air to flow.

High frequencies are more directional than low frequencies and they also contain less energy. This means that you require less mass to contain their sound and thinner absorptive panels. Knowing this, let's apply these two concepts to a typical studio workstation setup using a three step approach:

Step 1 Add a front door
Most project studios employ a desk of come sort as a workstation. The computer is often located out of the way under the desk in a computer 'tunnel' that includes a low lying shelf which is open at the front and in the back. The noise is escaping from both access points. So the first thing to do is to add a solid door to the front. Most hardware stores sell a variety of standard kitchen cabinet doors and these can be custom ordered to fit. The best choice of door will be a good heavy one made from melamine as it will contain more sound. Bring your desk opening drawing with you so that the hardware specialist can recommend the best hinge to suite your particular need. If you want to get a glass door, try to get one that has a good heavy pane of glass and make sure it does not rattle. Most doors are designed to expand and contract so they do not glue the panel inside the rails. If your door rattles, add a silicone bead. You should also apply good weather stripping to surround the door opening. Remember, if air can pass so will noise.

Step 2: Absorb the noise before it gets out
Now that the noise exiting the front of the cabinet will be significantly reduced, we have to treat the noise inside the tunnel itself. Think of it this way: by reducing the noise at the source, it will be mush easier than trying to deal with it after it escapes! Remember: Because we need to provide the computer with fresh air, we cannot simply put another door on the back. Enclosing the computer would result in recycling hot air which of course could cause your system to overheat.

The best way to quiet down the noise is to line the inside of the tunnel with 1" thick Broadway panels. You should line the sides and top and even the front door if you can. Just make sure you leave sufficient space so that air can flow. Because the whirr of the computer fan is usually quite high, the 1" thick panels will provide effective results. All you need is standard construction adhesive some 1.5" finishing nails and some Broadway panels. For safety, it is always best to use fiberglass panels. Urethane foam panels can dry out and end up causing a dust problem for your computer which could clog up the fan or create problems in the electronics. Fit the panels inside the tunnel best you can to cover the surfaces. You can then cut the panels to fit by first pulling the excess fabric out of the way and then re-gluing it to cover the edges. Add a bean of adhesive around the perimeter and then X from corner to corner. Use a couple of finishing nails to hold the panels in place to allow the glue to set.

Step 3: Control the noise exiting the tunnel
The final step involves doing what you can to reduce the noise that is exiting the back of the tunnel. This is done by treating the wall (or walls) behind the desk. Remember, high frequencies are directional. This means that the exit port of the tunnel where your computer lives has now become a horn. The direct sound exiting the horn will reflect off any adjacent walls and follow a vector. By treating the wall you will eliminate these reflections. You can use 1" thick Broadway panels to do this or if you happen to have some extra 2" panels, you will increase the attenuation.

Although this 3 step approach will not completely eliminate computer noise, it will do wonders at reducing the noise problem without breaking the bank. This do-it-yourself project is easy to do and it will definitely help lower the residual noise your studio.

 





Primacoustic is a division of Radial Engineering Ltd. © 2008 Tel: 604.942.1001 | Fax: 604.942.1010